Trainwreck’s next chaotic episode P.I. Moms drops on Netflix this week, and I can’t wait to learn why this story was canceled on Lifetime 20 years ago
As far as Netflix documentaries are concerned, Trainwreck is doing some heavy lifting across June and July: we’ve had weekly rollouts including Poop Cruise, The Cult of American Apparel and Balloon Boy, and this week it’s the turn of P.I. Moms. The new installment tells the story of a group of soccer moms turned private investigators, who were supposed to have their story told in a 2010 series for A&E Network’s Lifetime channel.
If you think the name or premise is vaguely familiar, that’s because the series was canceled before it ever made it to air. As it turns out, there was an even bigger scandal brewing behind the camera than there ever was in front, leading straight back to the P.I. agency’s boss, Chris Butler.
Thankfully, Trainwreck: P.I. Moms deep dives into the various allegations that were unearthed by the original reality TV show’s production team, and you can bet your bottom dollar that it gets juicy. Personally, I can’t thank Netflix enough for their efforts to brew the perfect bingeable storm 20 years on.
Netflix’s Trainwreck: P.I. Moms lifts the lid on canceled documentary brought down by agency drug scandal
As I’ve started to explain, Trainwreck: P.I. Moms explores allegations made by Lifetime’s production team against Chris Butler, the boss of the P.I. agency in question. If Selling Sunset or the Real Housewives had made a private investigator team for reality TV, it would have looked like P.I. Moms, with the Bay Area private investigator firm staffed almost exclusively by soccer moms. Butler & Associates was owned by Butler, with only one other male member, Carl Marino, on staff.
The Lifetime show was supposed to be in the care of showrunner Lucas Platt, with the women themselves easily interesting and smart enough to make any type of end product an incredibly successful one. Obviously, that didn’t happen, and it’s probably less surprising to realise that was not down to the soccer moms. With wannabe actor Marino claiming he wanted a bigger role in the show, journalist Pete Crooks received alarming intel after being invited to do a ride-along with the moms for Diablo magazine. The most alarming part? The cases were being set up by Butler rather than being authentic.
After this initial discovery came more bad news for Lifetime, with reports of criminal activity within the agency, including drug dealing, illegal wiretapping, and even more staged phony sting operations. According to the US Sun, Butler had an ever longer list of allegations against him personally, such as undercover surveillance, decoy work in infidelity and domestic cases, general private investigations and assisting with “Dirty DUIs scheme”. These schemes involved getting female “helpers” to encourage men to drink and then get into a car, with corrupt police officers working with Butler to then pull the men over and arrest them for drunk driving.
The final nail in the reality TV coffin was Butler being convicted of drug dealing and running a brothel, unsurprisingly leading Lifetime to shut down production on the show. While four moms were affected by what happened, we hear from two in the new Netflix series: Denise Antoon and Ami Wiltz. The group previously appeared on Dr. Phil to discuss the potential scam, but this is the first time viewers have been given detailed access to the entire story from the inside.
Arguably, the worlds of reality TV and corruption have never been simultaneously explored in this way before, although Balloon Boy did begin to touch on some of these themes. In the words of RuPaul, I can’t wait to see how this turns out.
You might also like
As far as Netflix documentaries are concerned, Trainwreck is doing some heavy lifting across June and July: we’ve had weekly rollouts including Poop Cruise, The Cult of American Apparel and Balloon Boy, and this week it’s the turn of P.I. Moms. The new installment tells the story of a group…
